August 15, 2022

sopres silver

The finest in business

Comcast: Very Enticing Shopping for Alternative (NASDAQ:CMCSA)

Comcast: Very Enticing Shopping for Alternative (NASDAQ:CMCSA)

Comcast: Very Enticing Shopping for Alternative (NASDAQ:CMCSA)

Cindy Ord/Getty Photos Leisure


I like to start my articles, once I can, by reviewing any earlier protection I’ve shared on a inventory. In Comcast’s (NASDAQ:CMCSA) case, I first bought the inventory on the very starting of the March 2020 crash on February twenty eighth, 2020, and wrote about it a couple of days later in my article “Latest Purchase: Comcast“. Since then, the inventory value has been on a rollercoaster experience and the overall returns have primarily been even.

CMCSA total return price % Change
Knowledge by YCharts

As you possibly can see within the chart above, Comcast’s inventory principally mirrored that of the S&P 500 till about 9 months in the past, when there was a giant divergence in efficiency, with Comcast underperforming the index. I feel this divergence was unjustified and it is possible that Comcast now trades at an excellent relative worth in comparison with the broader market (which is what I will make the case for on this article).

Whereas I have not written any articles on Comcast since 2020 on Searching for Alpha, on my YouTube channel, I made a really clear case on 2/15/21 that Comcast inventory was a superior worth that Disney (DIS) and that Disney shareholders who needed publicity to comparable media property ought to promote Disney inventory and purchase Comcast as a substitute. Right here is how they’ve carried out since that video.

CMCSA total return price % change
Knowledge by YCharts

Whereas Comcast inventory is down since then, it’s down a lot lower than Disney inventory which has rightfully cratered -50%, and I feel even after the declines in each shares Comcast stays the higher various.

On this article, I’ll reexamine Comcast inventory and clarify why, even when now we have a recession and deep bear market, Comcast must be a greater relative worth than the S&P 500, and over the long run, might be a superb absolute worth as effectively.

How Cyclical Are Earnings?

Earlier than I start this evaluation, I will verify the enterprise’s long-term earnings patterns to be able to make sure that the enterprise is a correct match for this kind of evaluation. If the historic earnings 1) do not have a protracted sufficient historical past 2) are erratic in nature, or 3) are too cyclical, then I both keep away from analyzing the inventory altogether or I exploit a distinct kind of research that’s extra applicable.

Comcast's historical earnings trend graph

FAST Graphs

Over the previous 20 years, Comcast has grown earnings each single 12 months besides throughout the coronary heart of the COVID pandemic when parks and theaters have been fully shut down, and even then, EPS progress solely fell -17%. This is not a really cyclical enterprise total, and if not for the extraordinary circumstances of the COVID pandemic, traditionally Comcast has been, and nonetheless is, a secular progress firm. For shares like this, it’s applicable to make use of an earnings-based valuation evaluation just like the one I will use on this article.

Market Sentiment Return Expectations

To be able to estimate what kind of returns we’d anticipate over the subsequent 10 years, let’s start by inspecting what return we might anticipate 10 years from now if the P/E a number of have been to revert to its imply from the earlier financial cycle. Since now we have had a current recession (albeit an uncommon one), I am beginning this cycle in fiscal 12 months 2015 and operating it via 2022’s estimates.

Comcast's P/E ratio

FAST Graphs

Comcast’s common P/E from 2015 to the current has been about 17.73 (the blue bar circled in gold on the FAST Graph). Utilizing 2022’s ahead earnings estimates of $3.60 (additionally circled in gold), Comcast has a present P/E of 10.79. If that 10.79 P/E have been to revert to the typical P/E of 17.73 over the course of the subsequent 10 years and every part else was held the identical, Comcast’s value would rise and it might produce a 10-Yr CAGR of +5.09%. That is the annual return we will anticipate from sentiment imply reversion if it takes ten years to revert. If it takes much less time to revert, the return can be greater.

Enterprise Earnings Expectations

We beforehand examined what would occur if market sentiment reverted to the imply. That is totally decided by the temper of the market and is very often disconnected, or solely loosely linked, to the efficiency of the particular enterprise. On this part, we are going to look at the precise earnings of the enterprise. The purpose right here is straightforward: We wish to understand how a lot cash we might earn (expressed within the type of a CAGR %) over the course of 10 years if we purchased the enterprise at right now’s costs and saved the entire earnings for ourselves.

There are two fundamental elements of this: the primary is the earnings yield and the second is the speed at which the earnings will be anticipated to develop. Let’s begin with the earnings yield (which is an inverted P/E ratio, so, the Earnings/Value ratio). The present earnings yield is about +9.24%. The way in which I like to consider that is, if I purchased the corporate’s entire enterprise proper now for $100, I’d earn $9.24 per 12 months on my funding if earnings remained the identical for the subsequent 10 years.

The subsequent step is to estimate the corporate’s earnings progress throughout this time interval. I do this by determining at what charge earnings grew over the last cycle and making use of that charge to the subsequent 10 years. This entails calculating the EPS progress charge since 2015, taking into consideration every year’s EPS progress or decline, after which backing out any share buybacks that occurred over that point interval (as a result of lowering shares will improve the EPS as a result of fewer shares).

CMCSA shares outstanding % change
Knowledge by YCharts

Comcast has solely purchased again about 4% of the corporate since 2015, however I’ll modify for each these buybacks and 2020’s earnings decline in my earnings progress expectations. After doing that, I estimate an earnings progress charge of about +11.21%. That is somewhat extra conservative than the FAST Graphs charge of +12.35%.

Subsequent, I will apply that progress charge to present earnings, trying ahead 10 years to be able to get a closing 10-year CAGR estimate. The way in which I take into consideration that is, if I purchased Comcast’s entire enterprise for $100, it might pay me again $9.24 plus +11.21% progress the primary 12 months, and that quantity would develop at +11.21% per 12 months for 10 years after that. I wish to understand how a lot cash I’d have in complete on the finish of 10 years on my $100 funding, which I calculate to be about $273.54 (together with the unique $100). After I plug that progress right into a CAGR calculator, that interprets to a +10.59% 10-year CAGR estimate for the anticipated enterprise earnings returns.

10-Yr, Full-Cycle CAGR Estimate

Potential future returns can come from two fundamental locations: market sentiment returns or enterprise earnings returns. If we assume that market sentiment reverts to the imply from the final cycle over the subsequent 10 years for Comcast, it’s going to produce a +5.09% CAGR. If the earnings yield and progress are just like the final cycle, the corporate ought to produce someplace round a +10.59% 10-year CAGR. If we put the 2 collectively, we get an anticipated 10-year, full-cycle CAGR of +15.68% at right now’s value.

My Purchase/Promote/Maintain vary for this class of shares is: above a 12% CAGR is a Purchase, under a 4% anticipated CAGR is a Promote, and in between 4% and 12% is a Maintain. That makes Comcast a “Purchase” at right now’s value. (I take small, 1% weighted positions when utilizing this technique.)

An Extra Consideration: Recession P/E

The second consideration with Comcast has to do with downcycles and Comcast inventory’s possible decline throughout a recession. Since I’ve judged we’re presently late within the financial cycle, I desire to not maintain shares which are more likely to fall dramatically throughout recessions, and I’ve offered a lot of the shares in my portfolio which have a historical past of deep value or earnings declines throughout recessions (with a couple of exceptions), which is what I’ve spent most of my time writing about this 12 months.

For the less-cyclical shares that I am presently shopping for, I require that their ahead P/E ratios be decrease than earlier recession-low month-to-month common P/E ratios. Under I’ve illustrated the deeper ones over the previous twenty years for Comcast.

Comcast's historical recession P/E ratios

FAST Graphs

Presently, Comcast’s ahead P/E ratio is decrease than all of its different trough month-to-month P/Es. It is presently even decrease than the P/Es skilled throughout the Nice Recession and the COVID crash in March of 2020, so it meets this customary.

So Why Is It Priced This Low-cost?

I feel there are a few the reason why it is priced so low cost. The primary cause is that mainly all media shares have had an incredible sell-off. As I famous earlier, Disney has offered off twice as a lot as Comcast, and Netflix (NFLX) has fallen 3x as a lot. I feel Comcast is a minimum of partially being unjustifiably thrown out with shares like Disney that truly deserved to unload that a lot. So, I’d describe a part of the explanation for the sell-off as pushed by sentiment and momentum causes. As a longer-term investor, these do not concern me.

The extra reliable potential cause for the sell-off is the expectation of cord-cutting by customers that may damage Comcast’s cable enterprise, which is its main enterprise. I feel this can be a affordable fear for longer-term traders. Nonetheless, I feel that if this cordcutting development is gradual sufficient, that Comcast will be capable of adapt over time.

A fast anecdote: I truly was a really early cordcutter. Again earlier than 2009, once I first purchased and moved into my home, I lived in residences. If cable was included, that was high-quality with me, however I by no means paid for it immediately. After I first moved into my home in January of 2009, my native cable firm (not Comcast) provided me a very low cost introductory charge for an web/cable bundle, and so I signed up. When costs moved as much as regular after the primary 12 months, I canceled, and paid for some low cost DSL web by way of Century Hyperlink. I’d by no means pay what they charged for cable (which amazingly nonetheless included commercials!). So, for effectively over a decade we used simply primary web, Netflix and Amazon Prime at my home. And 12 months by 12 months, the number of streaming content material obtained higher. So, I feel cable is a particularly poor worth, personally.

Nonetheless, most individuals aren’t like me. Even when they do not need cable, they nonetheless want web and Comcast has that, too, and in lots of locations the place individuals dwell, there are restricted rivals. Certain, now we will get high-speed web over our telephones, however the quantity of knowledge most individuals want goes to exceed what they’ll cheaply get via their cell phone service. It is a lot better, particularly should you earn a living from home as many individuals do now, to have a reliable high-speed land-line connection. We had a brand new firm start-up in our city so I now have fiber from a cable competitor, however I nonetheless know many, many individuals who wouldn’t have that possibility and their cable firm nonetheless has the higher hand in the event that they like to observe tv (significantly sports activities), which many individuals do.

My level right here is that we do not understand how quick the cord-cutting will occur or what the final word impact will likely be on Comcast, however should you assume, as I do, it will likely be a comparatively gradual course of and that Comcast could have time to regulate and develop their different companies within the meantime, then a inventory buying and selling at a 10-11 P/E, when the market common is 50% greater than that, is an honest guess to make.

Moreover, the reopening of the financial system post-COVID ought to assist Comcast’s parks and leisure companies, and so they have already proven with Peacock that that they had essentially the most rational marketing strategy for streaming, when each Disney and Netflix are struggling to adapt.


There are numerous shares on this market that benefitted from stimulus and COVID whose earnings expectations are wildly optimistic over the subsequent 6-9 months. As a result of Comcast was not handled as a COVID winner, its inventory has remained moderately priced the previous couple of years. Not like Disney, whose earnings nonetheless have but to recuperate from the downturn, Comcast’s earnings have totally recovered already, and have some reopening catalysts nonetheless in entrance of them. Certain, if now we have a recession, Comcast will in all probability undergo like many different companies, however I do not assume they’ll undergo as a lot as a result of they’re already priced for a recession.

All that mentioned, my valuation methodology is designed for an unconcentrated portfolio, so I don’t recommend taking a place greater than a 1% or 2% portfolio weighting, with out performing deeper work.